Showing posts with label Adam Ting. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Adam Ting. Show all posts

Friday, March 12, 2010

Final Project, Final Post


Fulfillment of Design Goals: My main goal for this chapel was to provide an environment that encourages and facilitates reflection and introspection, and I feel my project should be evaluated with regards to how well it has accomplished that design goal as well as the overarching project goal of: "to astound us, astonish us with the play of light within the chapel..[through the use of] expressive light" (from the assignment handout). The above picture shows (with wall removed) what that expressive light looks like. The Chapel Sanctuary in general, and this gesture in particular is where I focused most of my effort on this project. I feel this particular lighting scheme provides both focus and inspiration. Focus because the main "light line" really leads you down to the altar (and lines are extremely straight forward because you can only follow them, you can't get "derailed"), and inspiration because of the sweeping ocean and reflected gestures on the side. This focus and inspiration is a requirement that I felt was critical to encourage introspection and reflection.

lighting when the sun is southeast

lighting effect when sun is south


What went well (other than expresssive light)
: Besides the main lighting feature, a lot of time and effort went into siting, and I felt that my final decision made a lot of sense for a number of reasons. Looking is also a nice foil to reveal my other strengths. So, if we compare my final and original site placements...



I think looking at these two pictures shows a lot about what this project was really about for me. It was about finding ways to relocate these buildings to provide order and meaningful sequences for people while making programmatic sense. Ultimately, and though I was reluctant, it meant recentralizing the buildings. I think this helped out aesthetically too, because it made it easier to develop one vocabulary instead of needing to develop ones for the other buildings. Also, the final design has the Chapel literally at the center of the space, and was successful at using the main Chapel mass to divide public and private space which I struggled to accomplish earlier.

A lot of this project (being a first studio and all) was learning how to go through the process, and all the blogging I've done was a little for you, but mostly for the sake of process capture, and learning to think about how I'm actually spending my time and what I'm doing. So aside from lighting and siting, that's the other strength I've really had.

3 STRENGTHS: expressive lighting, siting, and process capture.



Room for improvement: I really wish I had more time to develop the landscaping elements. In fact, there are many things I didn't get to due to time constraints, and some I did that just weren't as strong as my lighting. In no particular order, they are:
waterfall siting space
water flows outside of the main wall
main entrance
chapel lobby/entrance
development of path language to encourage people to move one way or another

I think the comments on relocating my entrance to the site were spot on, as were those on the lobby. My main "how to" is:
How might I relocate the entrance to the site to encourage circulation towards the chapel, while not eliminating the initial wall (not the massive one, but the one on the side of the classroom) I felt was crucial to separating the spaces?

Overall, I'm happy with the result of this project. Though I didn't get to some things I wanted to, and wish I had a little more time to develop some things, I felt I did a reasonable job of accomplishing the design goals and project criteria, while getting things done in time.


beloved detail: sitting space cut away from mass (the negative space + mass) is a scaled version of the classroom space (see aerial view below)



Monday, March 8, 2010

Chapel Progress


Circulation: I've settled on a final floor plan. I decided to choose the one that had the simplest circulation plan (everything is being simplified to it's essence): an entrance on the central axis of the chapel, with a crossing for bathrooms and a walkway to the classroom on the sides, and the chapel sanctuary dead ahead.


Proportion: Above is an elevation view (w/out the topography) of (from left to right) the side chapel, chapel, and classroom. They follow a 4, 5, 3 proportion system: the side chapel being 16' from ground level, the chapel 20', and the classroom 12'. This proportion system was meant to bring more order to the chapel compared to the previous model (below).


Prototyping: One last prototyping phase; I'm trying to mix it with construction so that I can make minor tweaks as needed. One strategy: tape buildings in place before glueing (pic above). It sounds obvious and simple, but it works very well, especially for identifying errors in measurement of cut pieces.


Construction: I've started the tedious process of putting my chapel together.
Step 1) Construct the base, and affix interior walls. I started here, because we need to make sure you can remove the roof, and since my roof will be attached to my exterior walls in the chapel sanctuary, needed to have a way to remove those too. Because my floor heights are different in the chapel, clasroom, and side chapel, this has been difficult. I wanted the ramp flush with the model, so after building the based, I attached the ramp and relevant walls. See below...




Step 2) Put together exterior chapel walls & light well support beams for altar. A notch was cut in one of the walls to just fit exactly as it needs to around the classroom chapel connection corridor.


After the walls with beams were constructed (it's neat how in this case, they really are necessary for structural integrity since I couldn't get this to stay without connecting the beams), I slid them into the structural base, and got the framed effect I had been trying for.



Step 3) Tinker with Ceiling/Roof, Expressive Light in Chapel


Step 4) Bring together main chapel with side chapel & classroom. Construct altar.


Left to Do: Ceilings and Roofs for all buildings need to be finalized, as well as a re-evaluation of fenestration. Site needs to be put up so that door for side chapel can be placed at correct level. Materials also may need to be reconsidered in entry to main chapel, since I'm not sure whether I like the low level of contrast between walls.

Saturday, February 20, 2010

Process: Site Plans

Below are the two site plans I'm considering:



The one above has been the design I've stuck with for a long time, and I feel it's more effective in perspective (3D) than in plan. Below is my newly considered site plan. Though I was originally reticent to change things, I feel like there's more order to this building placement, and between the 3 key structures, more interaction.



Contrary to the picture in the previous post, I decided to have the classroom, chapel, and side chapel all look out at different angles (each 7.5 degrees different b/c that was the proportional grid system I've been working with). I feel that this is a strong gesture in plan, but I'll have to wait until I model it to see how helpful it is in reality. Some problems to resolve with this design:
1) There seems to be an awkward interaction between the southeast corner of the Chapel and Northeast corner of the classroom.
2) The northeast corner of the church feels very "sharp". Not sure how to make this feel like less of a point, how to give it more mass?
3) "The wall" feels extremely long now. In the plan above, I tried to solve this by experimenting with the roof of the office, extending it out over the "path" to a triangular island. Not sure how I feel about this; my goal was to frame a zen view from when you enter the complex, and look left towards the ocean, but instead move right to get to the chapel, classroom, etc.

Thoughts?

Friday, February 19, 2010

Process Update: Chapel Details, still more site placement (maybe...)

The Chapel has started to take form, and with it a unifying design language for the entirety of the project. I started this process by going back to the fundamental design goal of this project (as well as keeping in mind my personal ones as the architect): the use of expressive light to provide a safe, encouraging, and inspired environment for reflection and introspection. My design inspiration was the below picture from one of the power points we were given (I can't find what bldg. it came from, or who the architect is).


Something about the "line" of glazed glass made the whole experience of prayer really simple to me (my eyes kept following it up and down), and I felt that I could take advantage of that to bring peoples eyes/attention to the alter. The visual effect also is one that creates a very vertical sense to the space, almost as if the ceiling extends into the heavens, and I wanted to create that effect because I felt it fulfills my desire to provide a very inspired space, not one that is dull.

I decided to focus first on the line of glass windows (to bring people to look at the altar), and then design expressive light for the altar itself. The below sketches show my initial ideas in how I thought this might work. The last picture shows additional light wells I was exploring, and have not constructed in my section model (if I will construct them).





My goal would be for people to enter the chapel, look up at the ceiling (because it is much higher than the previous space they were in), follow the line of glass all the way down to the altar, then follow it back up so they're really focusing on the ceiling, and then "turning" to themselves.

The section construction process began in Sketchup (after sketches).


I then built the model originally as shown below.


I later decided that having the light just focused on the altar would help to be focused, but might make the room to dark and scary, so decided to open up slits on both side walls so light can shine down. Below shows the lighting effects.



There was a little modification to the site plan too. The below pics show the two configurations I'm currently considering. I'm also considering moving the side chapel to inside the chapel.

Sunday, February 14, 2010

Process: More site placement, and massing studies
















After figuring out a base barrier/wall system for the site, I decided to work with trace and chipboard initially to explore bldg. placement. This proved to be a difficult task: given the fact you don't know exactly how your bldgs will be shaped, how should you site them? I found that having the Chapel at the front of the site (mostly down hill) allowed me to place the classroom in ways such that I could have 2 circulation spaces (I only recently realized that I should make these distinct by having one public, and one private.



















When I moved to using the site model (3D), the whole picture changed. You can see how I tried using similar manipulations of translation, rotation to try and create effective relationships between buildings and circulation spaces. Most of the time, I'm trying to be aware of site lines. In the above pictures, I had been playing around with where exactly I wanted to site the chapel. I had decided on making the side wall of the classroom to "entrance wall" to the complex, and needed a way to cite the chapel to have an effective public circulation space to the south of the chapel and west of the classroom. After being unsatisfied with the previous transformations, I decided to try something different, and cut the end of the chapel off. This is where I planned on having the entrance/lobby, but now I wanted to see how I might be able to free up space close to the classroom. This became an effective solution, and will now be used in my project, because in essence this entrance is now functional as a kind of "welcome center" for the whole complex: people will enter, turn left at the wall and descend the stairs, and then the first bldg. they will come to will be the entrance center. They can either cross the plaza to the classroom, head into the lobby and then past it into the chapel (via an enclosed path), or head south to the side Chapel. By placing the bathrooms in here (behind a wall, which I've already designed and feel will be very effective), they become very accessible to all.


Above is the current design, with the problem solved chapel placement and lobby. I also am exploring the positioning of the office on top of the classroom. Note the two clear circulation areas: the public one in the middle of the site, and the private one on the northeast part (also a little private space for the side chapel). I feel like a lot of problem solving has gone into this final site placement: a lot of manipulations and thoughts that something would be final, only to tweak it more and get things right. One more thing to figure out: how to get the chapel at just the right angle (because it's currently just off of the 15 degree offset from North grid that so many other buildings are based off of).